^{Source: Retirable}

My grandmother is in her late 70s and currently holds about $400,000 in stock market investments. She also owns a $250,000 home, though she has an outstanding mortgage with a relatively low interest rate. Her financial situation includes retirement savings and a pension, allowing her to live comfortably without tapping into her stock portfolio.

While I don’t want to sound alarmist, I worry about her exposure to market fluctuations, especially with economic uncertainty and her ongoing mortgage obligations. She lives frugally and only has around $5,000 in cash savings. Given her financial position, should she consider selling some investments to pay off her home loan?

Concerned Grandchild

Expert Financial Insights: Is Selling Stocks the Right Move?

Your Grandmother’s Financial Picture: A Strong Foundation

First, it’s important to recognize that your grandmother is in a solid financial position. With $400,000 in stock investments, a pension, and a paid-in retirement account, she is better off than many retirees. Given her low-interest mortgage, maintaining a diversified portfolio that includes cash, stocks, bonds, and real estate is key.

Currently, her assets are distributed as follows:

• 61% in stocks
• 38% in real estate
• Less than 1% in cash

A more balanced allocation might include at least 30% in cash reserves, ensuring liquidity for emergencies.

Does It Make Sense to Pay Off the Mortgage?

Paying off a mortgage can provide peace of mind, but it isn’t always the best financial decision. Here’s what to consider:

• Mortgage Interest Rate: If her interest rate is below 5%, keeping the loan and investing elsewhere may yield higher returns.
• Liquidity Needs: Selling stocks to pay off the mortgage would reduce her liquid assets, limiting flexibility for unexpected expenses.
• Tax Considerations: If she has a low-cost basis in her investments, selling could result in significant capital gains taxes.

Financial planner Martin Schamis highlights that investments in nonqualified accounts receive a step-up in basis upon the owner's death, reducing tax burdens for heirs. Given her current comfort with mortgage payments, maintaining the loan might be the wiser path.

The Broader Economic Landscape: Should Retirees Worry?

Market volatility and geopolitical concerns, including wars in Ukraine and Gaza, as well as U.S. economic policies, are fueling fears among investors. Recent fluctuations have been influenced by the Federal Reserve’s monetary policies and global trade tensions.

Stock Market Trends: Bullish or Bearish?

Economic data offers mixed signals:

• Positive Indicators:
  • Unemployment rate remains low at 4.1%.
  • GDP growth exceeded economists' expectations.
  • Inflation has dropped from 9.1% (June 2022) to 2.8% (February 2024).
• Concerning Signs:
  • The U.S. federal deficit now exceeds 6% of GDP, double what it was a decade ago.
  • The Federal Reserve remains hesitant to cut interest rates significantly.
  • Consumer confidence recently hit a four-year low.

Economists remain divided—Harry Dent predicts a 2008-style market crash, while Oppenheimer expects a 17% rise in the S&P 500. The reality is likely somewhere in between.

How to Safeguard Retirement Finances Without Panic

Diversification: Key to Reducing Risk

Financial advisors emphasize the importance of diversification in times of market uncertainty. Rather than selling all stocks, consider the following steps:

1. Increase Cash Holdings: Selling a portion of investments to build a 6- to 12-month emergency fund.
2. Assess Portfolio Risk: Rebalancing to include more bonds and dividend-paying stocks.
3. Tax-Smart Selling: Utilizing strategies like tax-loss harvesting to minimize tax burdens.
4. Charitable Donations: Donating appreciated stocks to reduce taxable gains while supporting causes.

Michael Brennan, a tax advisor, notes that selling positions in IRAs is generally tax-free, and careful timing of portfolio drawdowns can significantly impact financial stability.

Long-Term Perspective: Staying the Course

Historically, stock markets recover from downturns, and long-term investors tend to fare better than those who react emotionally to short-term swings. Your grandmother’s financial habits—building a portfolio over 50 years—suggest she understands this principle.

Rather than making drastic moves, consider adjusting her asset allocation gradually while ensuring she has adequate liquidity for any future needs, including long-term care expenses.

Final Thoughts: Protecting Your Grandmother’s Financial Future

Your grandmother is in a strong financial position, and while adjusting her portfolio for stability is wise, selling all stocks outright may not be necessary. Instead, focus on:

• Increasing her cash savings.
• Balancing her portfolio to reduce risk.
• Making informed, tax-efficient investment decisions.

No one can predict the market’s future with certainty, but preparing for different scenarios will ensure she remains financially secure for years to come.

Your role? Support her in making thoughtful, informed choices—without panic, but with a plan.

‍