U.S. Stocks Struggle to Recover from Tariff-Driven Correction: What’s Next?

The Impact of Trade Wars and Policy Uncertainty on U.S. Stock Market Recovery

After just 16 trading sessions, U.S. stocks experienced a rapid and steep correction, sending Wall Street into a frenzy. With global markets reeling from President Trump's unpredictable trade policies and the escalating tariff war with major trading partners, investors are now left wondering how long this "adjustment period" will last. Historically, corrections have taken time to recover, but with the stakes higher than ever, the path forward is uncertain.

A Fast-Moving Correction: U.S. Stocks Hit Hard

The recent correction in the stock market was swift, with the S&P 500 index tumbling by more than 10% from its all-time high in just over two weeks. This sharp decline marks the seventh-fastest 10% drawdown in history, according to Bloomberg data. However, the speed of the downturn hasn’t been matched by a clear or consistent rebound, leaving investors on edge.

Despite a brief 1% rally earlier this week, stocks remain under pressure, down about 3% in the past five trading sessions alone. After the most recent drop, the S&P 500 has shed roughly $5 trillion in market capitalization since its February 19 peak, which had marked an all-time high.

The Historical Context: How Long Do Corrections Typically Last?

In the 24 previous instances where the stock market experienced a correction of at least 10% but avoided falling into a bear market, the average recovery took about eight months, according to data from CFRA Research. This pattern suggests that the February 19 high could remain out of reach until October, with the average drawdown in these cases reaching 14%.

But as history teaches us, no two corrections are alike, and predicting the future path of the market is more complex than simply following historical trends. Current economic uncertainty, driven by the impact of Trump’s trade policies and other unpredictable factors, means that forecasting recovery is a challenge.

A Bear Market on the Horizon?

Doug Ramsey, Chief Investment Officer of The Leuthold Group, has a more cautious outlook. He believes that the correction may just be the first leg down in what could evolve into a cyclical bear market. "We are looking at this correction as the first leg of a bear market, so we're not focusing too much on potential recovery scenarios just yet," Ramsey said. His reasoning? The market pullback could lead to slower economic growth, especially if wealthier Americans cut back on spending due to heightened uncertainty.

While the S&P 500 briefly bounced back, the market has continued to show signs of stress, including a 3.1% loss last week. The last round of declines came after Trump intensified his trade dispute with the U.S.'s largest trading partners, prompting concerns about broader economic consequences. Additionally, Trump's administration is pushing forward with plans for mass deportations and laying the groundwork for firing tens of thousands of federal workers, which only adds to the pressure on an already fragile labor market.

The Critical Question: Will This Correction Lead to a Recession?

The depth and duration of the selloff are closely linked to whether an economic downturn or even a recession is on the horizon. Ross Mayfield, investment strategist at Baird Private Wealth Management, stated, “Plenty of 10-15% selloffs have snapped back quickly if economic weakness is limited, or if there is a policy intervention to prevent a full market collapse, either from the government or the Federal Reserve.”

Bank of America’s Michael Hartnett suggests that the rapid market decline may prompt both the Trump administration and the Federal Reserve to intervene to prevent further losses. However, so far, there’s been little indication that the administration plans to adjust its stance, especially on trade issues. Economists warn that the April 2 tariffs set to affect all countries the U.S. trades with will likely lead to price pressures, further complicating the economic outlook.

Bear Market vs. Non-Recession Correction: What’s the Difference?

The key distinction between a non-recession correction and one that signals a bear market is significant. Historically, corrections during non-recession periods average a 16% drop, whereas bear markets tied to economic downturns can see a 36% decline in stock value. With the S&P 500 already losing significant ground, many traders are asking how much worse it could get.

If the market continues its descent, a bear market scenario—where stocks drop 25% or more—could send the S&P 500 to around the 4,700 level. As of Thursday's close, the index stood at 5,521, and further declines could represent a rough road ahead for investors.

Market Sentiment: Wall Street Shifts to a More Cautious Outlook

Investor sentiment is beginning to shift as many Wall Street firms adjust their expectations for the market. Goldman Sachs recently downgraded its S&P 500 forecast, reflecting the recent losses. Even Ed Yardeni, a prominent market bull, cut his forecast by about 9%, warning of stagflation risks due to ongoing tariff uncertainty.

Furthermore, the S&P 500's relative strength index (RSI) currently sits at 27, a level that indicates the market is extremely oversold. This marks a level seen in less than 1% of instances this century, according to market analysts. While this suggests that the market is primed for a potential bounce, the ongoing trade and economic uncertainties still weigh heavily on investors’ minds.

Kevin Gordon, Senior Investment Strategist at Charles Schwab, pointed out, “If we remain in this on-again, off-again tariff environment, businesses will be flying blind, unsure of how to plan for the future.” The behavioral shift in the market has caused investor pessimism to grow, and Gordon believes that a full recovery may require a “behavioral washout phase” to reset market sentiment and prepare the stage for a rally.

The Bottom Line: Can the Market Bounce Back?

While the road ahead remains uncertain, a key point of focus is whether the market can stabilize amid ongoing tariff volatility and economic policy shifts. If the current correction continues to deepen, it could evolve into a bear market, but with quick intervention from the government or the Federal Reserve, the damage may be limited.

For investors, the situation remains fluid, and careful monitoring of economic data, trade developments, and monetary policy will be crucial in determining whether a recovery is on the horizon or if the market will face prolonged uncertainty.

Stay tuned for more updates and detailed analysis as this situation develops.

‍